| Contestant | Original Tribe | Merged Tribe | Finish |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basketball | Night Owls | 16th/15th | |
| Marker | Snow Wolfs | 16th/15th | |
| Crayon | Night Owls | 14th | |
| Salt | Snow Wolfs | 13th | |
| Apple | Night Owls | 12th | |
| Cherries | Night Owls | 11th/10th | |
| Soap | Snow Wolfs | 11th/10th | |
| Poptart | Snow Wolfs | 9th | |
| Teddy Bear | Night Owls | 8th | |
| Poptart | Snow Wolfs | Rainbow Stars | 9th |
| Fiery | Night Owls | Rainbow Stars | 8th |
| Apple | Night Owls | Rainbow Stars | 7th/6th |
| Match | Snow Wolfs | Rainbow Stars | 7th/6th |
| Lightbulb | Snow Wolfs | Rainbow Stars | 5th/4th |
| Bow | Night Owls | Rainbow Stars | 5th/4th |
| Marshmallow | Snow Wolfs | Rainbow Stars | 3rd |
| Cookie | Night Owls | Rainbow Stars | 2nd |
| Pencil | Snow Wolfs | Rainbow Stars | 1st |
| Original Tribes | Merged Tribe | ||||||||||||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Episode #: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | |||||||||||
| Voter | Vote | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| Eliminated: | Basketball (7/8) Marker (7/8) | Crayon (6/7) | Salt (6/7) | Apple (5/6) | Cherries (4/5) Soap (4/6) | Poptart (4/5) | Teddy Bear (3/4) | Poptart (8/9) | Fiery (5/8) | Match (3/7),Apple(4/7) | Ligtbulb(3/5),(Bow 2/5) | Marshmallow (2/3) | |||||||||||
| Pencil | Marker | Salt | Soap | Poptart | Poptart | Fiery | Apple | Lightbulb | Marshmallow | ||||||||||||||
| Cookie | Basketball | Crayon | Apple | Cherries | Teddy Bear | Poptart | Bow | Match | Bow | Marshmallow | |||||||||||||
| Marshmallow | Marker | Salt | Soap | Poptart | Poptart | Fiery | Apple | Lightbulb | Cookie | ||||||||||||||
| Lightbulb | Marker | Salt | Soap | Poptart | Poptart | Fiery | Match | Bow | |||||||||||||||
| Bow | Basketball | Crayon | Apple | Cherries | Teddy Bear | Poptart | Fiery | Apple | Lightbulb | ||||||||||||||
| Apple | Basketball | Crayon | Fiery | Poptart | Bow | Match | |||||||||||||||||
| Match | Marker | Salt | Soap | Poptart | Poptart | Fiery | Apple | ||||||||||||||||
| Fiery | Basketball | Crayon | Apple | Cherries | Teddy Bear | Poptart | Bow | ||||||||||||||||
| Poptart | Marker | Salt | Marshmallow | Marshmallow | Cookie | ||||||||||||||||||
| Teddy Bear | Basketball | Crayon | Apple | Cherries | Bow | ||||||||||||||||||
| Cherries | Basketball | Crayon | Apple | Cookie | |||||||||||||||||||
| Soap | Marker | Salt | Marshmallow | ||||||||||||||||||||
| Salt | Marker | Soap | |||||||||||||||||||||
| Crayon | Basketball | Teddy Bear | |||||||||||||||||||||
| Basketball | Crayon | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| Marker | Soap | ||||||||||||||||||||||
| Jury vote | ||
|---|---|---|
| Finalist: | Pencil | Cookie |
| Juror | Vote | |
| Marshmallow | Pencil | |
| Lightbulb | Cookie | |
| Bow | Pencil | |
| Apple | Cookie | |
| Match | Pencil | |
| Fiery | Cookie | |
| Poptart | Pencil | |